Who is seeding, and where
COMPILED SEPTEMBER 2026 · SOURCED THROUGHOUTCloud seeding is not a rumor and not a secret. In the United States it is a reported, permitted, contracted activity with a fifty-year paper trail; abroad it ranges from statutory transparency (Australia) to near-total opacity (China). This page is the census: every program this site can document, what kind of seeding it is, who flies or fires it, and where its records live.
Numbers below carry their class of evidence: RECORD a filed document · MEASURED an observation · MODELED a simulation · CLAIMED an operator's or government's own number. The distinction matters more on this page than anywhere else on the site.
Three kinds of seeding
| Type | Mechanism | Where practiced |
|---|---|---|
| Winter orographic (glaciogenic) | Silver iodide gives supercooled liquid water in mountain storm clouds an ice nucleus to freeze on; the crystals grow and fall as extra snow in the target watershed. | Utah, Idaho, Colorado, Wyoming, Nevada, California, Snowy Mountains (Australia), Morocco's Atlas. The best-understood kind, and the only one with direct physical proof of the full chain (SNOWIE, 2017). |
| Warm-cloud / hygroscopic | Salt particles give convective clouds bigger droplets to coalesce around, trying to nudge rain out of clouds that were close to raining. | Texas, UAE, Saudi Arabia, Thailand, India, Mexico. Much weaker evidence base than winter seeding. |
| Hail suppression & rain suppression | Seed heavily so many small ice particles compete instead of a few growing huge — or rain a cloud out offshore before it reaches the city. | North Dakota, western Kansas, west Texas, France (ANELFA), Mendoza (Argentina), Russia's North Caucasus, China; rain suppression in Indonesia and for Moscow's parade days. |
United States
REPORTED TO NOAA SINCE 1972 · PERMITTED BY THE STATESEvery non-federal U.S. project must file with NOAA before it starts RECORD — see The Records. The programs below are the operating core, largest first.
Utah — the largest U.S. program
State-supported winter seeding since 1974, run by the Division of Water Resources with North American Weather Consultants as operator. After a 2023 legislative expansion ($12M one-time plus $5M/yr RECORD), Utah now runs about 190 remotely controlled ground generators plus aerial and drone seeding — billed as the world's largest remote-controlled program CLAIMED. Season November–April, silver iodide. The state claims roughly +10% snowpack and ~200,000 acre-feet a year of added streamflow CLAIMED — target/control estimates, not a randomized result. Annual per-area reports with generator maps: water.utah.gov/cloudseeding. An independent 2026 re-evaluation from public data (Judy) found the storm-scale effect falls to +1.5% [−9.6, +13.1] once operator storm selection is designed out, with a ±6% noise floor under any seasonal claim MEASURED — worked in full as Forensic Case 002. Its by-product is the first public geocoded layer of Utah's generator network, mirrored here: /data/atlas/generators-ut-2024-25.csv (181 sites, 8 programs) with the per-area seeding timeline 1974–2026 in ut-seeding-treatment.json.
Idaho — the biggest acre-feet claims anywhere
The Idaho Collaborative Cloud Seeding Program pairs the Idaho Water Resource Board with Idaho Power, which has seeded since 2003. About 57 remote generators and three aircraft target the Payette, Boise, Wood River and Upper Snake basins, November–April RECORD. The partners claim about one million acre-feet a year combined CLAIMED — the largest published yield claim of any U.S. program. End-of-season reports: IDWR. Idaho is also where the physics was proven: the SNOWIE experiment flew here in 2017.
Texas — the biggest footprint by area
Roughly seven warm-season rain-enhancement projects over ~31 million acres — about a sixth of the state RECORD — permitted and licensed by the Texas Department of Licensing & Regulation, generally March–November. The big four: the West Texas (San Angelo), South Texas (Pleasanton), and Trans-Pecos (Fort Stockton) weather modification associations and the Panhandle Groundwater Conservation District — plus, since 2025, the venture-backed startup Rainmaker Technology Corp. on the Gulf Coast. Texas permits require newspaper notice and allow public hearings, and TDLR publishes a county-level project map.
Colorado, Wyoming, Nevada, California
Colorado: the CWCB permit program covers the San Juans, Grand Mesa, Gunnison, the Upper Colorado headwaters and ski-country programs — with built-in suspension criteria that halt seeding when snowpack runs too fat RECORD; Lower Colorado River Basin states help fund it. In late 2025 the CWCB also permitted a first-of-its-kind ionization array near Gill — "seeding" without chemicals, testing what a permit even means. Wyoming ran the field's most important U.S. randomized experiment (the $8.8M Weather Modification Pilot Project over the Medicine Bow and Sierra Madre) and has since shrunk to a ground-only program after the legislature cut airborne funding in 2025 RECORD. Nevada's Desert Research Institute program ($600K/yr since 2023) targets the Tahoe-Truckee, Ruby and Spring mountains and publishes per-season acre-feet estimates (~56,000 in 2023–24 at ~$11/acre-foot CLAIMED). California has run utility and county programs continuously since the early 1950s — PG&E on the Feather and Mokelumne, Santa Barbara County, the Kern River — catalogued in the state's Water Plan.
The hail belt
North Dakota's Cloud Modification Project has flown hail suppression and rain enhancement in the western counties since 1961 — June 1 to August 31, around the clock, flown by Weather Modification Inc. of Fargo, with annual operations reports filed publicly RECORD. Western Kansas has run a groundwater-district hail program since 1975 (~8,000 sq mi, April–September). Hail suppression is also the oldest continuous seeding tradition abroad — France's ANELFA generator network has run since 1952, Mendoza has defended its vineyards since 1959 (sixty years of reviews finding no statistically significant effect MEASURED), and Russia's North Caucasus rocket program is 65 years old.
The operators
THE CONTRACTOR LAYER MOST COVERAGE SKIPS| Operator | Base | Runs |
|---|---|---|
| Weather Modification Inc. / International | Fargo, ND | The largest aerial operator: North Dakota's project, the Wyoming pilot, contracts from Saudi Arabia to Morocco to India. |
| North American Weather Consultants | Sandy, UT | The oldest firm (1950): nearly all of Utah's target areas, Santa Barbara, Kern River. |
| Rainmaker Technology Corp. | El Segundo, CA | The venture-backed newcomer (2023): drones and aircraft in Texas, Utah and the Colorado River basin — and the center of the July 2025 Texas flood controversy (see Forensics). |
| SOAR | Plains, TX | Texas and New Mexico convective projects. |
| Desert Research Institute | Reno, NV | The research institution that also operates Nevada's program. |
| Rain Enhancement Technologies | Massachusetts | Ionization arrays (Gill, Colorado) — the non-chemical edge case. |
The world
| Country | Program | Type & scale | Public record |
|---|---|---|---|
| China | CMA Weather Modification Centre + offices in nearly every province | Everything at once — aircraft, rockets, artillery, generators; a plan covering 5.5 million km² for rain enhancement and claims of +168 billion tons of precipitation 2020–25 CLAIMED. The world's largest program by an order of magnitude. | None. Provincial announcements only. |
| UAE | National Center of Meteorology + UAEREP research grants | Hygroscopic, year-round, opportunistic — ~300 missions a year from four King Airs based at Al Ain CLAIMED. The April 2024 Dubai floods triggered a global "did seeding do this?" cycle; NCM said no missions flew into that storm. | Press releases; the aircraft themselves are trackable. |
| Saudi Arabia | National cloud seeding program (2022–) | Aircraft over six regions, ~750 flights since launch, kingdom-wide expansion CLAIMED. | Press releases. |
| Thailand | Dept. of Royal Rainmaking (royal project since 1969) | Warm-cloud "super sandwich" technique, ~30 aircraft, 2,065 flights in 2025 CLAIMED; also flies PM2.5 washout. | Government summaries. |
| Australia | Snowy Hydro, Snowy Mountains NSW | Winter orographic over ~2,110 km²; an independent evaluation of the randomized trial found +14% snowfall MEASURED. Paused after 2023 pending an infrastructure review. | The world's best: statutory annual compliance reports to the NSW EPA. |
| India | IITM research (CAIPEEX) + state operations; Delhi trials 2025 | Hygroscopic; the Solapur randomized experiment measured +18% over its 100 km² target MEASURED. Delhi's 2025 air-pollution washout trials found no rain in dry clouds. | Papers and press; state tenders. |
| Indonesia | BNPB disaster agency | Rain suppression — seeding clouds offshore to rain out before reaching flood-prone Jakarta. | Agency statements. |
| Morocco | Programme Al Ghait (1984–) | Atlas Mountains, aircraft and generators; ~70 operations in 2024 CLAIMED. | Ministry statements. |
| Russia | Roshydromet hail services; Moscow event clearing | Rocket hail suppression in the North Caucasus for 65 years; cloud clearing for parade days at ~$1.3M an event. | Literature; little operational record. |
| Israel | Discontinued 2021 | Fifty years of operational winter seeding ended after the Israel-4 randomized experiment returned +1.8%, statistically indistinguishable from zero MEASURED. The canonical cautionary tale. | The published experiment itself. |
Sources for every figure on this page are collected in the site's research corpus — NOAA filings, state permit files, program annual reports, and the primary literature. Independent market estimates put global cloud seeding at roughly $0.4–0.6B in 2025. Compiled September 2026; programs change yearly and this page will track them. The atlas is also published as data: /data/atlas/programs.json — 37 geocoded programs across 14 countries, each with type, operator, season, status and evidence-classed claims. The winter programs from this file are the silver rings on the Seedability map. For Utah, the atlas goes a level deeper: generators-ut-2024-25.csv (181 generator sites) and ut-seeding-treatment.json (per-area adoption timeline 1974–2026), mirrored with attribution from Judy 2026.